Proceedings · Session S-740 · filed November 18, 2026
Lab Technology & MethodsSession paper
3D-printed modulator cuts carbon-ion therapy delivery to 30 seconds
GSI and THM researchers cut carbon-ion delivery from minutes to ~30 s using 3D-printed patient-specific range modulators, with 99% target coverage in a lung case.
By Tom Whitfield3 min read697 words
Summary
- Delivery time fell from several minutes to ~30 s (four synchrotron cycles) using a single-energy beam
- All three modulators achieved >99% target coverage at 95% of the prescribed 3 Gy(RBE) dose
- Each synchrotron energy switch costs about 4 s; the 3DRM eliminates switching entirely
- A modulator has already delivered conformal FLASH irradiation of a lung target in 150 ms at GSI
- Modulator pin structures as small as 100–200 µm took the team 10 years to print reliably

A patient-specific 3D-printed range modulator has cut carbon-ion therapy delivery time from several minutes to roughly 30 seconds, while delivering at least 95% of the prescribed dose to over 99% of the target volume. Researchers at GSI Helmholtz Centre for Heavy Ion Research and Technische Hochschule Mittelhessen (THM) in Germany reported the results in Zeitschrift für Medizinische Physik, using a lung cancer patient case previously treated with photon radiotherapy.
The work targets a structural bottleneck in synchrotron-based facilities. Pencil-beam scanning covers a 3D tumour by switching beam energies layer-by-layer. Each switch costs about 4 seconds. Total delivery: several minutes. That's long enough for breathing motion in lung and liver tumours to distort the final dose distribution, and it rules out ultrahigh-dose-rate delivery.
What does the modulator replace?
Instead of switching synchrotron energy, the team, led by first author Hong-Ha Nguyen and senior author Uli Weber, uses a passive 3D range modulator (3DRM) that builds a spread-out Bragg peak from a single-energy beam. The modulator is a large set of pins, each with an individual thickness profile, that shapes dose in 3D to match the target.
"Because the modulator provides 3D dose shaping, we only need to deliver a single energy layer," Nguyen, a PhD student at GSI, explained. "This completely eliminates the delays from energy switching and reduces the overall delivery time from several minutes to just seconds."
The workflow runs on GSI's in-house TRiP treatment planning system. It converts a conventional multi-energy carbon-ion plan into a single-energy plan using passive energy degradation. TRiP models Coulomb scattering of carbon ions in the modulator material within its beam modelling, spot optimisation and dose calculation, and automatically generates the modulator design — each energy layer becomes an equivalent pin thickness, each 2D spot map becomes a matrix of pin-layer weights. High-precision 3D printing then manufactures the device.
How was it validated?
The case study produced three carbon-ion plans at modulator-to-target distances of 50, 70 and 100 cm. All used two coplanar beams, a fixed energy of 259.89 MeV/u, 3 mm spot spacing and a single-fraction dose of 3 Gy(RBE). The team 3D-printed all three modulators, integrated them into the beamline, and measured dose in a WERNER water phantom with a moving ionisation-chamber array.
All three achieved full single-energy target coverage, with over 99% of the target volume receiving 95% of the prescribed dose. The distance comparison quantifies the trade-off: larger modulator-to-target distances enlarge beam size at the target, raising dose to surrounding healthy lung tissue. Even so, all three plans kept organ-at-risk doses within clinical criteria.
The 30-second delivery corresponds to four synchrotron filling cycles — short enough to fit one or a few patient breath-holds, sharply reducing motion-induced dose errors. Measured distributions agreed well with both TRiP calculations and FLUKA Monte Carlo simulations.
How much faster could it go?
Thirty seconds isn't the floor. "The 30 s per field is currently limited by the number of ions the synchrotron can supply per cycle," Weber said. "With higher beam intensity, a field could be delivered in a single extraction lasting only a few seconds. At GSI, we have also used a modulator for a conformal FLASH irradiation of a lung tumour target in just 150 ms."
Clinical integration looks feasible to Weber, provided quality assurance protocols are adapted. One hurdle stands out: the modulators' pin structures run as small as 100–200 µm, and reaching the current printing precision took the team 10 years.
"Our group at GSI, together with the THM, was the first in the world to realise and prove this technique," Weber noted, adding that other institutes now use it for protons and that the first clinical patient studies of conformal FLASH with protons are beginning, including at the University of Pennsylvania.
Nguyen said the group is now preparing a publication on conformal FLASH irradiation with 3DRM at GSI using a high-intensity beam, aiming to demonstrate that the workflow extends to FLASH carbon-ion treatment in the clinic.
via sciencedirect.com (Original)
Filed under
- carbon-ion-therapy
- 3d-printing
- range-modulators
- treatment-planning
- flash-radiotherapy
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in research and development at Hypothesis Wire.
268 articles
References
- Siemens Healthineers launches Accela linac for 60-second SBRT
- MIT's portable 3D breast ultrasound lifts target detection to 79.7%
- Monte Carlo workflow quantifies motion damage in proton minibeam therapy
- Ultrasound drug delivery peaks at 15–23 nm, UVA team finds
- Leica Ships Laser Cassette Printer Rated at 2.5 Seconds Per Cassette