Proceedings · Session S-330 · filed November 20, 2026
Physical Sciences ResearchSession paper
Delft flips titanium-47 nuclear spin with two-frequency STM
Delft researchers flipped titanium-47 nuclear spins with a two-frequency scanning tunneling microscope. Responses near 50 and 85 MHz survived a tenfold mixing cut, but the mechanism remains unknown.
By Tom Whitfield4 min read723 words
Summary
- Titanium-47 nuclear spin changed near 50 and 85 MHz under a two-frequency STM protocol.
- The nuclear-spin response persisted after quantum mixing was reduced by a factor of ten.
- Prior Delft work measured a nuclear-spin state lasting about five seconds, roughly 10 million times longer than the electron-spin state in the same atom.
- Delft’s 2014 electric-field method manipulated nuclear spin through entangled electron–nucleus states.
- The study appeared in Nature Communications, with the operating mechanism still unresolved.

A two-frequency scanning tunneling microscope flipped the nuclear spin of titanium-47 atoms at response points near 50 and 85 MHz, and the effect survived a tenfold reduction in electron–nucleus quantum mixing.
The Delft University of Technology team, led by condensed matter physicist Sander Otte, used a modified instrument to deliver a refined electromagnetic field to exposed titanium-47 atoms. The study appeared in Nature Communications.
What did the two-frequency setup measure?
The experiment separated probing from actuation. A gigahertz signal interrogated the electron and carried a resonance signature of the nuclear state. A lower megahertz signal then swept the range where the titanium-47 nucleus was expected to respond.
By tuning the microwave coupling to the electron’s spin, the team could read the deeper nuclear state without first wrapping the nucleus in entanglement with its electromagnetic surroundings.
As the second signal swept, the nuclear spin changed at roughly 50 and 85 MHz, although the electron–nucleus link should have made the nucleus effectively insensitive to the microscope’s electrical signals.
The shift persisted after the team reduced quantum mixing by a factor of ten. The account gives no atom count, uncertainty estimates or replication count and names no research funder; the result is a measured observation, not yet a quantified reliability benchmark.
Why did the result break the expected rules?
Spin gives particles angular momentum, but quantum spin is point-like and quantized into two directions rather than a literal rotation with measurable speed. Electron spin is comparatively accessible and underpins technologies from refrigerator magnets and Earth’s protective field to electronics and quantum computing.
Protons and neutrons also carry intrinsic spin, which combines into a nucleus’s total spin. That nested signal is harder to measure and manipulate; its weakness may also protect quantum information from environmental disturbance.
In 2014, Delft researchers manipulated nuclear spin through the interplay between an atom’s electric field and its nucleus. Their method effectively poked the atom’s electromagnetic shell, making the core respond through entangled electron–nucleus states.
The new result matters because it seeks to alter the nuclear spin without that same environmental entanglement. Sander Otte said: “According to our simple understanding, this should not really happen. The nuclear spin should not be sensitive at all to the electrical signals from a scanning tunneling microscope.”
Could this become single-atom NMR?
The proposed payoff is nuclear magnetic resonance at the scale of one atom, using scanning tunneling microscopy, a comparatively common laboratory technique. That could provide a way to change nuclear spin while keeping it outside the web of environmental entanglement and, potentially, supply a robust quantum bit.
Delft reported the relevant advance the previous year: a nuclear-spin state that lasted about five seconds, roughly 10 million times longer than the electron-spin state in the same atom. That longevity is the measured asset; a single-atom NMR instrument or practical qubit remains a projection.
In another development this year, scientists in Singapore used the older electric-field method to create what the account calls potentially the world’s most accurate clock, based on quantum-spin motion in a lutetium nucleus. The summary provides no accuracy figure, so that comparison cannot yet serve as a performance specification for the Delft result.
What mechanism still needs to be proved?
The microscopic explanation is not established. One possibility is that the microscope method generated an oscillating magnetic field near the atom, although the research team describes that route as unlikely. The observed frequency response and its persistence are measured; the microscopic account is not.
For R&D managers, the immediate portfolio question is not whether titanium-47 can answer an STM signal, because the reported data say it can. The question is whether the coupling can be reproduced selectively, retained without environmental entanglement and converted into a repeatable control operation across many atoms.
The next gate is therefore mechanism and metrology: disclose atom counts, uncertainty, linewidth or frequency stability, and the coherence needed for clock or qubit work. Until those data arrive, the experiment supports a research direction for single-atom spin control, not a deployable instrument.
If Delft can explain the 50 and 85 MHz switching and reproduce it at lower mixing, the two-frequency STM workflow could advance the proposal to apply nuclear magnetic resonance to single atoms.
via newatlas.com (Source)
Filed under
- scanning-tunneling-microscopy
- titanium-47
- nuclear-spin-control
- condensed-matter-physics
- single-atom-nmr
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in research and development at Hypothesis Wire.
280 articles